International Tax Issues: Transfer Pricing, DTAA, and Double Taxation
Introduction
In an increasingly globalized world, businesses no longer operate within the boundaries of one country. Multinational corporations (MNCs) manufacture goods in one nation, assemble them in another, and sell them across many others. While globalization has boosted international trade and investment, it has also created complex challenges in the area of taxation. Questions arise about where profits should be taxed, how to prevent the same income from being taxed twice, and how to stop companies from evading taxes by shifting profits to low-tax countries.
Three important concepts that address these concerns are transfer pricing, Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA), and the broader issue of double taxation. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial for ensuring fairness, preventing tax evasion, and promoting economic cooperation between nations.
Understanding Double Taxation
Double taxation refers to a situation where the same income is taxed in two different countries. This generally happens when a person or company is a resident of one country but earns income in another. For instance, if an Indian company has a branch in the United States, both India and the U.S. may claim the right to tax the profits earned in the U.S. This leads to duplication of tax liability and discourages cross-border trade and investment.
Double taxation can be of two types:
1. Juridical Double Taxation – When the same person is taxed on the same income in two countries.
Example: An Indian resident earning salary in the U.S. is taxed in both countries.
2. Economic Double Taxation – When two different persons are taxed on the same income.
Example: A company is taxed on its profits, and shareholders are again taxed on dividends received from that company.
Such situations are unfair and create financial burdens for taxpayers. To address this, countries enter into Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs), which provide relief and clarity on how and where income should be taxed.
Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA)
A DTAA is a treaty between two countries designed to prevent the same income from being taxed twice. The main aim is to promote international trade and investment by providing certainty to taxpayers about their tax liabilities.India, for example, has signed DTAAs with more than 90 countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Singapore. These agreements specify which country has the primary right to tax certain types of income such as salary, dividends, royalties, capital gains, and business profits.
There are two major methods of relief under a DTAA:
1. Exemption Method – Income is taxed only in one country.
Example: If a DTAA states that business income will be taxed only in the country where the business is carried on, then the resident country will exempt it.
2. Credit Method – Income is taxed in both countries, but the home country gives credit for the tax paid abroad.
Example: If an Indian resident pays tax on income earned in the U.S., India will allow a deduction for the tax paid in the U.S. when calculating the Indian tax liability.
Apart from these, DTAAs also include provisions to exchange information between tax authorities, prevent tax evasion, and settle disputes through mutual agreement procedures.
Transfer Pricing: The Heart of International Taxation
While DTAAs aim to prevent double taxation, transfer pricing rules are designed to prevent tax evasion through artificial profit shifting.Transfer pricing refers to the pricing of goods, services, or intellectual property transferred between related entities within a multinational group. For instance, if an Indian subsidiary of a U.S. company buys raw materials from its parent company, the price set for that transaction is the “transfer price.”
The problem arises when these prices are manipulated to reduce overall tax burden. MNCs often shift profits to low-tax jurisdictions (known as tax havens) by overpricing or underpricing intra-group transactions. This reduces taxable income in high-tax countries and increases profits in low-tax countries, ultimately lowering the total global tax paid by the group.To counter this, tax authorities apply the Arm’s Length Principle (ALP). According to this principle, the price charged in a transaction between related parties should be the same as if they were unrelated and dealing independently in an open market.
Arm’s Length Principle and Transfer Pricing Methods
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) provides detailed guidelines for determining arm’s length prices. The most common methods include:
1. Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) Method – Compares the price charged in a controlled transaction (between related entities) with the price charged in an independent transaction.
2. Resale Price Method – Begins with the resale price to an independent party and subtracts an appropriate gross margin to arrive at the arm’s length price.
3. Cost Plus Method – Adds a reasonable profit margin to the supplier’s costs to determine the appropriate price.
4. Profit Split Method – Divides the total profit from a transaction between related entities based on the relative value of their contributions.
5. Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) – Compares the net profit margin from a controlled transaction with that from similar independent transactions.
In India, transfer pricing regulations were introduced in 2001 under Sections 92 to 92F of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Companies involved in international transactions are required to maintain detailed documentation and justify that their transfer prices are at arm’s length. Failure to comply can attract heavy penalties.
Challenges in International Taxation
Despite existing mechanisms, several challenges persist in international taxation:
1. Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS): Many MNCs exploit loopholes to shift profits to low-tax jurisdictions. The OECD’s BEPS initiative aims to close these gaps through international cooperation.
2. Digital Economy: Companies like Google, Amazon, and Meta operate digitally and can earn huge profits from a country without having a physical presence there. This raises questions about how to tax such profits fairly.
3. Tax Havens: Jurisdictions with zero or minimal taxes attract artificial profit shifting. Regulating such practices remains a major concern for developing countries.
4. Complex Compliance: Maintaining transfer pricing documentation and understanding DTAAs require high expertise and cost, especially for small enterprises operating internationally.
India’s Approach and Global Efforts
India has been proactive in addressing international tax issues. Apart from detailed transfer pricing rules, India introduced Country-by-Country Reporting (CbCR) and Master File requirements to ensure transparency. These reports provide information about global allocation of income, taxes, and business activities of multinational groups.India is also a member of the OECD-G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS, which works toward a global solution for taxing digital and multinational businesses. The introduction of Equalisation Levy in India is another example, which ensures that foreign digital companies pay their fair share of taxes on revenues earned from Indian users.
Globally, the move towards a Two-Pillar Solution under OECD’s framework where Pillar One reallocates taxing rights and Pillar Two sets a global minimum tax rate marks a significant step towards equitable taxation.
Conclusion
International tax issues like transfer pricing, double taxation, and the role of DTAA lie at the core of global economic cooperation. While DTAAs prevent double taxation and promote cross-border trade, transfer pricing laws ensure that multinational companies pay their fair share of taxes where real economic activities occur.
However, as the global economy becomes more digital and interconnected, tax laws must keep evolving. A fair and transparent international tax system is not only essential for protecting national revenues but also for maintaining trust among nations and ensuring that globalization benefits everyone not just a few large corporations.
Also Read:
Rights of undertrial prisoners in India
How To Send A Legal Notice In India
