Emerging Torts: Cyber Torts and the Challenge of Internet Harassment

Introduction

The digital age has revolutionized human communication, transforming how we interact, express opinions, and conduct business. However, with the rapid expansion of the internet, social media, and digital platforms, new legal and ethical challenges have emerged. Among them, cyber torts — wrongful acts committed in cyberspace that cause harm to individuals or organizations — have become a serious concern.

One of the most alarming forms of cyber torts is internet harassment, which includes online abuse, stalking, defamation, and invasion of privacy. As technology evolves, the boundaries between free speech and harmful conduct blur, compelling the legal system to redefine traditional tort principles in a virtual context.

This article explores the concept of cyber torts, their forms, legal implications, and the growing challenge of internet harassment in India and globally.

Understanding Cyber Torts

A tort is a civil wrong that causes injury or harm to another person, for which the aggrieved party can seek compensation through civil courts. Traditional torts—such as defamation, trespass, and negligence—were based on physical acts or face-to-face interactions.

However, with the emergence of the internet, these wrongful acts have shifted to cyberspace, where perpetrators can cause serious harm through virtual means. Thus, cyber torts can be defined as civil wrongs committed through electronic means or digital platforms that infringe upon the legal rights of others.

Cyber torts cover a wide range of wrongful acts, including:

• Online defamation

• Cyberstalking and harassment

• Data theft or privacy invasion

• Identity theft and impersonation

• Cyberbullying

• Publication of obscene or offensive material

These actions may not always fit neatly into existing legal categories, making them a developing and complex area of tort law.

Nature and Scope of Cyber Torts

Cyber torts are distinct from traditional torts in several ways:

1. Borderless Nature:
   The internet transcends geographical boundaries. A person in one country can commit a tort against someone in another, creating jurisdictional complexities.

2. Anonymity of Perpetrators:
   Cyber offenders often hide behind fake profiles or use anonymous networks, making it difficult to trace and punish them.

3. Speed and Scale of Harm:
   A defamatory post or leaked image can reach millions within seconds, amplifying the harm and making damage control nearly impossible.

4. Permanent Digital Record:
   Once published online, harmful content often remains accessible even after deletion, prolonging the victim’s suffering.

5. Overlap with Criminal Law:
   Many cyber torts also constitute crimes under cyber laws, blurring the distinction between civil wrongs and criminal offences.

Because of these unique features, cyber torts challenge traditional legal systems that were designed for an offline world.

Types of Cyber Torts

1. Online Defamation

Defamation involves the publication of false statements that harm a person’s reputation. Online defamation, often referred to as cyber defamation, occurs when such statements are made on digital platforms—such as social media, blogs, or online news portals.
For instance, spreading false allegations on Twitter or posting defamatory content on Facebook can amount to a cyber tort.

Indian courts have recognized online defamation as actionable under Section 356 (defamation) BNS, and also as a civil wrong under tort law.

2. Cyberstalking and Harassment

Cyberstalking involves continuous online harassment, threats, or surveillance intended to intimidate or control another person. This can occur through emails, messaging apps, or social media platforms.
It often targets women and minors, leading to psychological trauma and fear.

Under Section 78 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), stalking (including online stalking) is a criminal offence, and victims can also file civil suits for damages.

3. Invasion of Privacy

With the growing use of personal data online, privacy violations have become common. Unauthorized access to private photos, emails, or social media accounts can amount to an invasion of privacy—a recognized tort in India following the Right to Privacy judgment in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017).

4. Cyberbullying

Cyberbullying refers to repeated online abuse or humiliation, often targeting individuals through offensive messages, memes, or doctored images. It is especially harmful to young people, leading to mental health issues and even suicide in extreme cases.

5. Identity Theft and Impersonation

Creating fake social media accounts or stealing someone’s identity to cause harm, defraud others, or spread misinformation constitutes a cyber tort. Victims can sue for damages due to loss of reputation or emotional distress.

6. Data Breach and Misuse

Unauthorized use or leakage of personal data, including financial or health information, can lead to civil liability. As data becomes the new “oil” of the digital age, protecting it against misuse has become an urgent concern.

Internet Harassment: A Growing Threat

Internet harassment is one of the most disturbing forms of cyber torts. It refers to the use of digital technologies to threaten, abuse, or humiliate a person repeatedly. This includes:

• Sending threatening or obscene messages

• Posting offensive comments or personal information online

• Spreading rumors or doctored photos

• Engaging in “doxxing” (publishing private information)

• Conducting online smear campaigns

Victims of online harassment—especially women, journalists, and public figures—often face long-term psychological harm, reputational loss, and withdrawal from digital spaces.

Real-world Impact

• Emotional and Psychological Trauma: Victims experience anxiety, depression, and fear.

• Reputation Damage: False allegations or leaks can permanently affect careers and relationships.

• Chilling Effect on Free Speech: Many victims hesitate to express opinions online due to fear of backlash or trolling.

Legal Framework in India

India does not have a separate legislation specifically addressing cyber torts or internet harassment, but several existing laws provide partial protection.

1. Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000

The IT Act deals primarily with cybercrimes, but some of its provisions overlap with civil liability:

• Section 66A (now struck down) earlier penalized offensive online messages.

• Section 66C & 66D: Deal with identity theft and cheating through impersonation.

• Section 67: Punishes publication or transmission of obscene content in electronic form.

• Section 43A: Provides compensation for failure to protect personal data, introducing an element of civil liability.

2. Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023,

Provisions such as Sections 78 (stalking, Section 356 (defamation), and Section 79  (insulting modesty of a woman) can be invoked for online harassment cases.

3. Civil Remedies under Tort Law

Victims can seek:

• Injunctions to stop the harassment or remove defamatory content.

• Damages for mental agony, loss of reputation, or privacy invasion.

• Declarations of wrongful acts by the court.

Judicial Response and Case Studies

Indian courts have gradually recognized the seriousness of online wrongs.

• In Suhas Katti v. State of Tamil Nadu (2004), one of India’s earliest cybercrime cases, the accused was convicted for posting obscene messages about a woman in an online forum.

• In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court struck down Section 66A of the IT Act, emphasizing the need to balance free speech and protection from abuse.

• The Delhi High Court in several cases has ordered social media platforms to take down defamatory or harassing content, recognizing victims’ right to privacy and dignity.

These cases show the judiciary’s proactive role, though enforcement remains a challenge.

Challenges in Regulating Cyber Torts

Despite legal safeguards, several hurdles persist:

1. Jurisdictional Issues: Offenders can operate from anywhere in the world, making enforcement across borders difficult.

2. Anonymity and Pseudonymity: Identifying perpetrators behind fake profiles is complex.

3. Lack of Awareness: Many victims do not report incidents due to fear, shame, or ignorance of legal remedies.

4. Slow Legal Process: Civil suits for online harm often take years to conclude.

5. Platform Accountability: Social media companies are reluctant to take responsibility for user-generated content.

These challenges highlight the need for updated laws and faster remedies in cyberspace.

Global Perspective

Many countries have taken steps to address online harms through specialized laws:

• United Kingdom: The Online Safety Act seeks to hold platforms accountable for harmful content.

• United States: While free speech is protected, civil suits for defamation or privacy invasion are allowed.

• European Union: The GDPR imposes strict liability for data misuse, offering compensation rights to victims.

India, while progressing, still needs a comprehensive framework to tackle cyber torts systematically.

Way Forward

1. Comprehensive Cyber Tort Legislation: India needs a specific law recognizing and addressing civil wrongs in cyberspace.

2. Speedy Grievance Redressal: Special cyber tribunals or fast-track courts can ensure timely justice.

3. Digital Literacy: Awareness campaigns should educate citizens on their online rights and remedies.

4. Stricter Platform Regulations: Social media intermediaries must remove abusive content quickly and cooperate with law enforcement.

5. Privacy and Data Protection: Early implementation of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 can strengthen accountability for data misuse.

Conclusion

Cyber torts represent the new frontier of civil wrongs in an interconnected world. Internet harassment, in particular, exposes the darker side of online freedom—where technology empowers not only creativity but also cruelty.

While India’s legal system has made progress, much remains to be done. Protecting individuals from online harm requires a balance between freedom of expression and the right to dignity, privacy, and safety.

As the digital world continues to expand, the law must evolve accordingly — ensuring that the internet remains a space for empowerment, not exploitation.

Also Read:
Rights of undertrial prisoners in India
How To Send A Legal Notice In India