Bail and Custody under the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015

Introduction

The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 represents a reformative approach toward handling juveniles in conflict with the law. The Act aims to balance the need for rehabilitation and reformation of minors with the requirement of accountability for more severe crimes. Two key aspects of this legislation are the provisions related to bail and custody for juveniles, which significantly differ from the general criminal law system applicable to adults. These provisions prioritize the welfare of juveniles, recognizing that minors involved in criminal activities should not face the same punitive measures as adults.

Provisions on Bail

Section 12 of the Juvenile Justice Act governs the bail provisions for juveniles:

1. Right to Bail: Unlike the bail procedures for adults, the Act mandates that juveniles are entitled to bail as a matter of right, regardless of the severity of the offense (whether bailable or non-bailable). This is in line with the rehabilitative intent of the law, where detention is seen as a last resort.
   1. Conditions for Denial: Bail can be denied only under exceptional circumstances, including:
      • If the release of the juvenile would expose them to moral, psychological, or physical danger.
      • If the release would result in the child being associated with criminal elements.
      • If releasing the juvenile would likely result in obstruction of justice.
2. If bail is denied for these reasons, the child must be placed in an Observation Home, which is a temporary shelter for juveniles, rather than being placed in jail or police custody.

Provisions on Custody

Custody under the JJ Act is designed to be rehabilitative rather than punitive, focusing on the care and protection of the juvenile:

1. Observation Homes: Juveniles are placed in Observation Homes during the inquiry or trial. These homes serve as shelters where juveniles receive care, counseling, and education while their case is being processed.
2. Special Homes: In cases where a juvenile is found guilty of an offense, they may be placed in a Special Home. These homes provide long-term care and rehabilitation, including vocational training and education, aiming to reintegrate the juvenile into society.
3. Children’s Court: If the crime is classified as heinous (such as murder or sexual assault) and the juvenile is between the ages of 16 and 18, the Juvenile Justice Board may transfer the case to a Children’s Court. If convicted, the juvenile will not face imprisonment but will continue to receive rehabilitative care, reflecting the Act’s focus on restorative justice.

Requirements for Bail and Custody

For both bail and custody under the JJ Act, the guiding principle is the welfare and rehabilitation of the child. The system is structured to:

1. Protect the juvenile’s rights while ensuring they do not pose a threat to themselves or others.
2. Provide access to rehabilitation programs rather than punitive measures.
3. Ensure juveniles are kept in specialized facilities like Observation Homes or Special Homes and are not subjected to harsh police custody or imprisonment, which could have detrimental effects on their development.

Court Interpretations

1. Sheela Barse vs. Union of India (1986): This case emphasized the protection of juvenile rights, stressing that children should not be detained in jails or adult facilities. It laid down guidelines for how juveniles should be treated in custody.
2. Pratap Singh vs. State of Jharkhand (2005): The Supreme Court addressed issues of juvenile age determination, holding that juveniles should receive the benefits of the JJ Act’s protective provisions even in heinous cases.
3. Shilpa Mittal vs. State of NCT of Delhi (2020): The court ruled on the interpretation of “heinous” offenses, clarifying that not all serious crimes committed by juveniles fall under the purview of being tried as adults unless specific conditions are met.

Conclusion

The Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, through its provisions on bail and custody, reflects India’s commitment to a child-friendly justice system. By mandating the use of rehabilitative methods over punitive measures, the Act aligns with international standards and acknowledges the vulnerability of children in conflict with the law. While the law provides flexibility in dealing with heinous offenses, its core remains rooted in safeguarding the rights and future of juveniles, ensuring their reintegration into society as responsible citizens.

Also Read: 

Rights of undertrial prisoners in India
How To Send A Legal Notice In India